2023 ABC News Internet Ventures. Only Mike Murphy. The Afghan refused putting his entire family and community at risk. Some of the guys who had been in Afghanistan said it was just about a direct replica of the camp the United States destroyed after 9/11. Over and over during training, we were told never to be complacent, reminded constantly of the sheer cunning and unpredictability of our terrorist enemy, of the necessity for total vigilance at all times, of the endless need to watch out for our teammates. As Russell Watson alluded to above (4 years ago in response to a ridiculous article), he was not among the 4 soldiers on the ground who were the core of movie's story. Contact Bruce Newman at 408-920-5004. Each of the six of us in that aircraft en route to Afghanistan had constantly in the back of our minds the ever-intrusive rules of engagement. That's kind of why I think it's the best war movie ever made. The SEALs were attacked by as many as 200 fighters obviously tipped off by the goat herders. That was really where we were blooded for battle, combing those urban streets, ?ushing out insurgents wherever they hid. The SEALs fled into a gulch and tried to contact their base, first via radio, then with their satellite phone. The politicians have chosen to send us into battle, and that's our trade. And always more young men quite happy to take that shortcut to the trumpets, get right over that bridge and plug into some quality happiness. According to the screenplay, Gulab helps: According to the book, none of this happened. Two MH-47 Special Operations Aircraft, two UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters and two AH-64 Apache attack choppers were sent to the area. They may not have been the precise same guys who planned 9/11. Excerpted from LONE SURVIVOR: . Solomon Suh, who moved in with his daughters family after his sons death, used to drive down from Benicia on Sundays and spend the day with the bronze likeness of his son, who was 28 when he died, occasionally reading to him from the Bible. He'd been to our home in Texas, and he and I had been together for a long time in SEAL Delivery Vehicle Team 1, Alfa Platoon. The wholevillage was bound by Pashtunwali an ancient code that obligated a community to protect a guest, regardless of the cost. Concentrate. Axelsons body was eventually found a mile from his comrades, and based on the number of ammunition magazines he carried, the after-action report by the Navy suggests he kept fighting after being wounded multiple times. Ten thousand feet up some treeless moonscape of a mountain range in one of the loneliest and sometimes most lawless places in the world. The guys who traveled from Bahrain with me were remarkably diverse, even by SEAL standards. And they said, Yes, we know. . American troops boarding a helicopter in Afghanistan Fortunately, his neighbor, Billy Shelton, was a US Army veteran. I simply do not want to see some of the best young men in the country hesitating to join the elite branches of the U.S. Armed Services because they're afraid they might be accused of war crimes by their own side, just for attacking the enemy. Axe was a tall (6'4"), quiet man who was very smart. Their primary target, however, was a group of buildings that intelligence claimed were used by Shahs group. We continued our operations, looking for the key insurgents, forcing or bribing the information out of them. The black ?ags worked. Sometimes, with a particularly valuable terrorist leader, we might go in and get him, trying to yank him out of there alive. By now, late August, the question of the missing WMDs was growing more urgent. We didn't mind this, but we didn't love it either. "Lone Survivor," the story of SEAL heroism in the mountains of Afghanistan, resurfaced in May 2016 after an article in which Mohammed Gulab, the man who saved lone SEAL survivor Marcus Luttrell, disputed some of the most important aspects of Luttrell's story.Lone Survivor was eventually made into a major motion picture, but that . why wasn't james suh in lone survivorwhat is the indirect effect of temperature on orcas. That may sound callous, but your teammates are absolutely relying on the colleague with the grenade, because the guy upstairs might also have one, and that danger must be taken out. The goal of /r/Movies is to provide an inclusive place for discussions and news about films with major releases. Marcus Luttrell Didnt Pull a Bullet From His Leg. And then I'd be charged with murder. We used to hang out together half the night, and I can truthfully say no one ever made me laugh like that. You can also follow the show on Twitter. Pentagons chief of Naval Operations, and one of the many high-ranking military officials who personally meets with, Pope and leader of the Catholic Church from 1978 to 2005, and greatly admired by. Suh was one of 16 troops. So they just went right back at it. We worked usually in a very small unit of four SEALs. Despite all our efforts, the suicide bombers just continued, young Iraqis convinced by the teachings of the extremist ayatollahs that the murder of their perceived enemies would open the gateway to paradise for them - that the three trumpets would sound and they would cross the bridge into the arms of Allah and everlasting happiness. On April 14, 2003, he joined the invasion of Iraq with SEAL Team 5. The Korengal and Shuryak valleysthe geographic region of Operation Red Wingsare sparsely populated and could not support an enemy force of 200 people. There were times when he and I did not see eye to eye. But, of course, that is not the most signi?cant question. All rights reserved. That's frogmen, by the way, which we all were. The scene where one of the QRF SEALs pulled his handgun on the pilot demanding him to turn around and not leave those on the ground to die was very powerful even though it was brief. It would have been a whole hell of a lot quicker to head directly northeast across the gulf. Often the photographs had been taken by the team I worked in, and identi?cation was swift. And there's a whole code of conduct to remember when you ?nally catch up with him. Afghanistan. As a child, he already knew what he wanted - to become a Navy SEAL, a member of the elite special operations unit that was the cream of the US military. Suh was one of 16 troops killed when a MH-47 Chinook helicopter was shot down in Afghanistan on June 28, on a daring daylight mission to reinforce an outnumbered four-man SEAL reconnaissance squad in 8,000-foot mountainous terrain. Sorry, I meant dude. They failed. They offered Gulab money in exchange for Luttrell. Joe Rogan fans were left puzzled after a recent podcast episode with former Navy SEAL Marcus Luttrell ended abruptly when the war hero who inspired the movie "Lone Survivor . I can say from ?rsthand experience that those rules of engagement cost the lives of three of the ?nest U.S. Navy SEALs who have ever served. Luttrell makes this very clear in the memoir: They wanted me, but they. Crew Chief. Easily the best war movie to focus on the modern Middle Eastern conflicts. We always made certain the blast was aimed inward, just in case someone was waiting behind the door with an AK-47. I remember it like it was yesterday, someone pulling open the door to our barracks room, the light spilling out into the warm, dark night of Bahrain, this strange desert kingdom, which is joined to Saudi Arabia by the two-mile-long King Fahd Causeway. Well pause. Saddam was deposed by the U.S. and its allies during the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Stay right where you are." (This is when they settle down for tea. Some of them just had their front faade, the entire rear area having been blown out by U.S. bombs as the troops fought to run down the murderous Saddam Hussein. Taliban leader _________ is responsible for killing over twenty United States Marines, as well as villagers and refugees who were aiding American forces. Sign In. They would, and did. The Iranian navy does its exercises down there, operating out of their main base at Bandar Abbas and also farther down the coast, at their increasingly active submarine base. I had moved out onto the sidewalk, my ri?e raised, as I ?red to provide cover for my teammates. Author and lone surviving navy seal from the book Lone Survivor. What followed was Army Jump School, SEAL Qualification Training, Special Operations Combat Medic training (SOCM), as well as advanced emergency medicine and battlefield life support. For money. You had to serve out here in the Middle East to understand fully the feeling of danger, even threat, that was never far away, even in countries generally regarded as friendly to America. He was the son of a Navy SEAL, and his quiet, rarely uttered ambition was to be just like his dad, James J. Patton. Like Bahrain. He was an incredible man. And you should have seen his traveling bag. Around that time, with the search for weapons of mass destruction still under way, we were detailed to the gigantic Lake Buhayrat ath Tharthar, where supposedly a large cache had been hidden by Saddam. re blindly around a corner, aiming at nothing in particular, and end up killing three passing Iraqi civilians. I really wanted them to land because after watching what 4 SEALS can do imagine what an additional 16 could do. For me, it began in Iraq, the ?rst murmurings from the liberal part of the U.S.A. that we were somehow in the wrong, brutal killers, bullying other countries; that we who put our lives on the line for our nation at the behest of our government should somehow be charged with murder for shooting our enemy. Bush was, Dictator of Iraq during the early years of the War on Terror. You could hardly meet a better person. I'm not saying that, given the serious situation, those elite American warriors might not have died a little later, but they would not have died right then, and in my view would almost certainly have been alive today. This landlocked country is where the SEAL members were dropped off. It took place in a mountainous area called Sawtalo Sar at the Pech District of Kuna Province. It seemed no matter what we did, no matter how many of these nuts we rounded up, how much explosive, bombs, or weapons we located, there was always more. Suh worked to help ensure al Qaeda terrorists could not train in, nor launch strikes from Afghanistan since their lethal attack on the World Trade Center in New York on September 11, 2001.James Suh was a U.S.-born citizen of Korean immigrants. Together, they grew up on a ranch in Texas filled with oak trees and grazing animals. "What the hell do you want that for?" Because everyone knows liberals have never been wrong about anything. I should have known better. Let's face it, al Qaeda means "the base," and in return for the Saudi fanatic bin Laden's money, the Taliban made it all possible. Eric . He was ?rst up, literally dragging me away. In combat he was a supreme athlete, swift, violent, brutal if necessary. They live together in an apartment in Coronado, CA and have a close relationship. Once the mission of the surveillance and reconnaissance team was compromised and that fact was relayed to higher headquarters, a qui. He was a little older than most of us and referred to us as his kids - as if he didn't have enough. First of all, the d**n thing is inaccurate, and in the hands of an hysteric, which most of them are, the guns spray bullets all over the place. The Brits had just taken Basra. Synopsis: Set during the War in Afghanistan, the film dramatizes the United States Navy SEALs mission Operation Red Wings, in which a four-man SEAL team was tasked to capture or kill Taliban leader Ahmad Shah. Christ, he's in trouble - that was my ?rst thought. He also found Luttrell with seven unused clips. . (including. 'Bye, Marcus." It was hard for me to identify with Shane because he was so different. Dietz was shot multiple times, but kept returning fire until he died. Watch on. So if you're feeling froggy, then you better jump, because this frogman's been there, done that and is going back for more. And we always have a very clear objective, usually just one guy, one person who is responsible for making the problem: the terrorist leader or strategist. That's what we believe. Marcus was found by the villagers at this location. Why the hell don't you take a shower? According to Luttrells account dramatized in vivid, often bloody, detail in the movie in the early hours of the operation, he, Axelson, Dietz and Murphy were still waiting for daylight when three goat herders stumbled upon their location. Rogan and Luttrell had been about to talk about politics when the podcast ended. Donna and Cordell Axelson were the driving force behind a memorial erected in Cupertinos Memorial Park in 2007, an effort she describes as therapeutic. The statue depicts Matthew who attended Monta Vista High School and James in commando gear, rifles ready. There is no ?ghting force in the world quite like us. This is a global militant Islamist organization founded by Osama bin Laden, Abdullah Azzam, and several other militants, at some point between August 1988 and late 1989, with origins traceable to the Soviet war in Afghanistan. No one ever thought he did. Thus far, those mountain men had been kicking some serious a** in their skirmishes with our military. Somehow, shifting positions in the big Hercules freighter, we were leaving behind a place which was systematically tearing itself apart and heading for a place full of wild mountain men who were hellbent on tearing us apart. . Heres how the screenplay reads: According to Luttrells memoir, however, he was not in mortal danger. Check out what time "This Week" airs in your area. You can learn more about the foundation here and, if you are a veteran suffering from combat trauma, you can apply to attend here. His buddies would probably call it supercool or some such word. As part of the mission, a four-man SEAL reconnaissance and surveillance team is tasked with locating Shah. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. From what I've read and watched, he was screaming at Marcus to help him out. Chinook Co-Pilot. Submissions should be for the purpose of informing or initiating a discussion, not just to entertain readers. I'd still shoot the sonofabitch. Former American soldier and Texas resident who trains the adolescent. We'd sometimes go out on patrol every day for weeks, and there seems to be no time to shower and no point in showering when you're likely to be up to your armpits in swamp water a few hours later. Sure, we knew they were still around, still trying to regroup after the United States had just about ?attened them in Afghanistan.